ARTIFICIAL PROBLEMS OF ARMENIAN STUDIES IN ACADEMIC SCIENCE

Authors

  • Hrachik Hakobjanyan ASPU

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.24234/journalforarmenianstudies.v3i66.120

Keywords:

language, culture, linguistic generalities, cultural distortions, scientific reconstructions

Abstract

The article touches upon a situation in the field of Armenian studies, which was initially created as a bogus receiving pseudo-scientific formulations, which in academic linguistics led to a false image of the commonalities of Armenian and the languages of the world. Historical-comparative linguistics should not accept the situation in which the number of Nostratic commonalities connecting Armenian to single non-Indo-European languages is greater than the number of the commonalities it has with all the Indo-European languages together. This has no interpretation in the framework of previous conceptions, and a new framework has not yet been proposed. By not raising the problem or avoiding it, linguistics cannot solve it. Recently, the situation has been intensified by the exceptional discoveries made by a number of new linguistic directions, according to which the age of Armenian as an independent language is increasing, the issue of the indigenousness of Armenians in the Armenian Highlands is proven. The image of the Armenian language branch in the Indo-European language family should also be changed, firstly, due to the unscientific alienation of the Armenian and Khetaluvian language branches, secondly, due to the extensive sameness of Sumerian and Basque (which have not been considered Indo-European so far) with Armenian (which is considered Indo-European), thus being presented as languages of the Armenian branch. The article poses the problem that academic linguistics should either scientifically interpret these inconsistencies, or accept the historical mistakes it has made in relation to the Armenian language.

References

Aghayan E. (1958), Hay lezvabanowt'yan patmowt'yown /History of Armenian Linguistics/, vol. 1, Yerevan, YSU ed.

Aghayan E. (1962), Hay lezvabanowt'yan patmowt'yown /History of Armenian Linguistics/, vol. 2, Yerevan, YSU ed.

Aghajanyan S. (2022), Gaghtnazerc'vac' hayalezow kaysrowt'yown /Declassified Armenian Empire/, Yerevan, Author's ed.

Armin A. (2007), Hnagowyn het'anosakan Astvac'ashownch Sasna c'r'er e'posy' /The Ancient Pagan Bible the Epic Poem “Daredevils of Sassoun”/, vol. 1, Los Angeles, "Diaspora" Public-cultural publishing house.

Davtyan A. (2014), Hayeren-showmereren y'ndhanrowt'yownneri bar'aran /Dictionary of Armenian-Sumerian Generalities/, Yerevan, Author's ed.

Martirosyan H. (2023), Haykakan jhayr'apatkerneri & hin ashxarhi grayin hamakargeri c'agowmnabanakan ar'nchowt'yownnery' /Genealogical Relationships of Armenian Rock Paintings and Ancient World Writing Systems/, academia.edu, http://www.iatp.am/culture/articles/martirosyan-am.pdf.

Nersesian V. (2013), Xet'ere՞n, t'e' hin hayeren /Hittite or Ancient Armenian/, Yerevan, Gasprint.

Jahukyan G. (1960), Lezvabanowt'yan patmowt'yown /History of Linguistics/, vol. 1, Yerevan, YSU ed.:

Jahukyan G. (1962), Lezvabanowt'yan patmowt'yown /History of Linguistics/, vol. 2, Yerevan, YSU ed.:

Sargsyan V. (2000), Baskeri c'agman ar'eghc'vac'y' & Haykakan ler'nashxarhy' /The Mystery of the Origin of the Basques and the Armenian Highlands/, Yerevan, "Asoghik" ed.

Safaryan V. (2003), Oronowmner «mer'ac'» lezowneri pant'eonowm /Investigations in the Pantheon of "Dead" Languages/, Yerevan, "Gladzor" University of Management.

Stepanyan L. (2015), «Hay-polinezyan lezvamshakowt'ayin y'ndhanrowt'yownner» /"Armenian-Polynesian Linguistic and Cultural Commonalities"/, Yerevan, "Jason" ed.:

Dyakonov M. (1968), Predystoriya armyanskogo naroda /Prehistory of the Armenian People/, Yerevan, Publishing House of the Academy of Sciences of the Armenian SSR.

Jaoshvili V. (1968), Naseleniye Gruzii: ekonomiko-geograficheskoye issledovaniye /Population of Georgia: Economic and Geographical Study/. Tbilisi, Official Data of the All-Union Population Censuses in the USSR in 1926 - 1979.

Downloads

Published

2025-03-27